Most of my blog posts are directed at Maryland nursing home lawyers and other plaintiffs’ lawyers. This blog post is directed to Maryland victims of nursing home neglect and abuse. They want to know if they can sue, who they can sue, what is going to happen, and what the likely outcome of the case might be.
Can I sue a nursing home?
Yes. Nursing homes and other elder care facilities can be sued just like any hospital, doctor, or healthcare provider. In fact, lawsuits against nursing homes are very common and frequently settled out of court. I’ll talk to you more about this below. But for now, if you fear is that you are afraid of going to trial in a nursing home case, that is a statistically very unlikely outcome. I know of two nursing home trials that have gone to trial in the last 7 or 8 years and scores of nursing home cases are filed every year. More on that later. But for now, if your stress level in suing a nursing home is going to trial, I think that stress is misplaced.
Nursing homes are not strictly liable for every accident or injury to one of their patients. Even with the best possible care and attention elderly patients will sometimes get sick or injured. So Maryland nursing home law is not going to allow you to bring a claim unless the nursing home did something, or failed to do something, that caused harm.
Let me tell you, mistakes are rampant in nursing homes. Pick up an inspection report at even a good Maryland nursing home, particularly in Baltimore or Prince George’s County. These people screw up and cut corners left and right.
Few nursing home residents in Maryland receive the best possible care and attention. The question is just whether nursing screwups are going to cause physical harm or death. Patients in nursing homes are frequently neglected and sometimes intentionally abused.
Even in the absence of blatant abuse or neglect nursing homes can also be liable for injuries or death resulting from medical malpractice or from poorly maintained facilities. When nursing homes get sued the claims typically asserted fall into one of the following categories: abuse, neglect, medical malpractice, and property liability. Below is a summary of each of these types of claims.
Nursing home abuse refers to some type of intentional, wrongful act or actions committed against a patient resulting in physical or mental injury. Nursing home residents are usually defenseless which makes them vulnerable to various types of intentional abuse. Abusive conduct is usually committed by nursing home staff members but the abuser can also be another patient. There are 3 basic types of abuse:
- Physical Abuse: acts of physical abuse come in a wide range of severity. Punching or assaulting a patient is clear-cut and indefensible abuse. Using excessive force on a difficult patient can also cross the line and be considered abusive. For example, if staff members don’t have the patience for a difficult patient and tie them to the bed or sedate them every day this can absolutely be considered abusive treatment.
- Mental Abuse: mental abuse of nursing home patients can also come in a variety of forms and levels. Verbally berating, bullying, or threatening a patient are common examples. Unfortunately, it is very difficult to sue a nursing home for mental abuse alone. You probably won’t be able to sue unless the mental abuse is accompanied by some level of physical abuse.
- Sexual Abuse: sexual abuse of nursing home patients does happen. It can sometimes be hard to discover. But if you can prove it you will have a very strong claim against the nursing home.
You don’t necessarily need to “catch” or identify the abusive staff member in order to sue the nursing home for abuse. Catching the bad guy in the act is obviously great and makes for a slam dunk abuse claim against the nursing home. But the truth is you don’t really need to name a bad guy or even a suspect in order to hold the nursing home liable for abuse. For example, if mom or dad has a new black eye or bruise every time you go to visit them and the nursing home cannot offer a valid explanation you have enough evidence to sue the nursing home for abuse. You don’t need to figure out exactly who has been doing the punching.
Nursing homes have an obligation to actively monitor and care for their elderly patients. A nursing home can be liable if it fails to take proper care of a patient and they are injured as a result. The question in claims of neglect is exactly what level of care was required. This may vary depending on the type of nursing home involved. Malnutrition is a common type of nursing home neglect claim. All nursing homes have an obligation to ensure that their patients are eating and drinking enough to stay healthy. With some patients this may require more than simply putting a tray of food in front of the patient. Nursing homes also have a minimum obligation to prevent physical injury to their patients so falls and bedsores are also common grounds for neglect claims.
Nursing homes provide patients with both living assistance and medical care and treatment. If a patient is injured during the rendering of medical care the nursing home can be liable for medical malpractice. Malpractice claims are somewhat different from claims based on ordinary negligence or neglect. In a malpractice claim, the question is whether the medical treatment provided by the nursing home or its employees was consistent with the accepted medical standard of care.
In a different sense, almost all nursing home negligence lawsuits in Maryland are medical malpractice cases. Because a nursing home is deemed to be a health care provider, Maryland law requires that any lawsuit brought against a nursing home for negligence be brought under the Health Claims Act. This requires the nursing home negligence lawyer to jump through additional hoops to bring a claim. But it has little practical effect on the case for an experienced nursing home attorney.
Nursing homes and rehabilitation centers can also be sued for premises liability. Premises or property liability refers to the liability of a property owner to maintain its facility in a safe condition. Slip and falls cases are the most familiar type of property liability claims. Nursing homes can be accountable for more than just a slippery floor. Elderly patients in nursing homes have special needs so the scope of premises liability for a nursing home is somewhat broader. Inadequate maintenance or poor design at a nursing home facility can be more likely to cause injury compared to a similar condition at another location. For example, suppose the carpet in the hallway at a nursing home has a pulled seam. In an office building, this might not create much of a hazard. Most people in an office building are not going to trip and fall over a pulled seam, and if they do, they probably won’t be seriously injured. For elderly patients at a nursing home, however, the same pulled seam could be very dangerous. Nursing home residents using walkers or canes are far more likely to trip and seriously injure themselves.
How Do I Report Nursing Home Abuse?
If you suspect nursing home negligence in Maryland, you should call a lawyer who specializes in nursing home lawsuits. But if you suspect abuse, you need to report that to protect your loved one and others. You should call the Maryland Office of Health Care Quality (OHCQ) at 410-402-8108. If you are uncomfortable doing this yourself, ask a lawyer to do it for you.
What Are Nursing Home Lawsuits Worth?
Compared to other types of civil lawsuits, such as medical malpractice, lawsuits against nursing homes have a relatively high success rate. Many claims against nursing homes are quickly settled before a lawsuit is even filed.
For those that do go to trial plaintiffs win over 60% of the time and damages exceed $1 million in 25% of the victories. The median amount of damages awarded by juries in nursing home cases is around $350,000.
- More on average settlement value of Maryland nursing home cases along with stories of successful nursing home lawsuits
Will My Nursing Home Case Settle or Go to Trial?
I can’t find anyone online who is talking about this issue like I am. Maryland nursing home cases rarely go to trial. If you bring a claim, you will likely have to answer written and oral questions. But there is only a small risk, statistically, of a Maryland nursing home suit going to trial.
Nursing Home Negligence Settlements & Verdicts
Below are summaries of verdicts and reported settlements from recent lawsuits involving nursing home negligence, abuse or malpractice from Maryland, Pennsylvania and Virginia.
$120,000 Settlement (Pennsylvania 2023): Wrongful death action in which the decedent, an elderly nursing home resident, suffered a left hip fracture when she fell out of her bed as it was being lowered. She eventually died from complications directly related to the hip fracture and that lawsuit alleged that the nursing home was negligent in failing to properly restrain her in the bed before moving it.
$200,000 Settlement (Pennsylvania 2022): The decedent was a resident at Buckingham Valley Rehabilitation & Nursing Center in Bucks County, PA. While under the care of the nursing home, he reportedly developed pressure ulcers, urinary tract infections, pneumonia, enterocolitis, C. diff, septic shock, tubular necrosis and acute renal failure and died. His estate contended the nursing home was negligent for failing to properly train and supervise its staff, and for failing to ensure a proper care plan had been developed, including wound site monitoring.
$200,000 Settlement (Virginia 2022): An elderly woman was a resident in the assisted care and memory unit at The Elms of Lynchburg, a nursing home facility in Lynchburg, Virginia. While at the facility she sustained serious injuries from an undocumented fall and died 3 days later from her injuries. The estate alleged that the nursing home provided negligent care which caused her death.
$150,000 Settlement (Pennsylvania 2022): A elderly female resident at The Oaks Assisted Living Community had been at the facility for 4 years when she began showing signs of increased confusion, tiredness, instability and wandering and a year later, required total physical assistance for mobility. Despite this, the nursing home did not implement proper fall prevention measures or transfer the plaintiff to a skilled nursing facility. She eventually fell, fractured her hip and died from complications related to the injury.
$200,000 Settlement (Pennsylvania 2022): a 77-year-old dementia patient, was transferred from a hospital to defendant St. Joseph’s Manor Nursing Home, where she fell and suffered a subdural hematoma and fractures to her left femur, left orbital floor, and nasal bone. The lawsuit contended the facility was negligent for failing provide a clear fall assessment plan.
$350,000 Settlement (Virginia 2021): Elderly female was a resident a nursing home in Norfolk, VA. After experiencing an earlier fall she was assessed as a fall risk and the facility adopted a care plan to help guard against the risk of falling, which included using a rollator (walker). A staff member at the facility failed to follow this plan and did not have her use the rollator when getting on a scale. She fell and suffered severe injuries, including a subdural hematoma.
Contact Us About Suing a Nursing Home
If you or someone you know has been the victim of nursing home abuse, neglect or malpractice contact our experienced nursing home neglect lawyers at 800-553-8082 or get a free online consultation. We can tell you whether you have a possible lawsuit against a nursing home and how much it might be worth.
- More nursing home settlement statistics
- Nursing home settlement values based on sample cases
- More thoughts on why nursing home cases do not go to trial in Maryland